Wednesday, May 8, 2013

Superman vs Batman


I love DC Comics, and my loyalty to the brand originates from my obsession with Superman. Clark has always been my favorite superhero, and after hundreds and hundreds of arguments about who would win in a fight, I'm going to present my side of the scuffle here. Superman is better than Batman. This isn't just about who to bet on in a brawl, it's also about who does their job better, and who is most deserving of your attention. Here are my justifications.


 #1: Batman protects a city, Superman protects a planet

Yes, I know that in the modern storylines, Batman has taken a much more global approach to crime fighting, by dividing his time between the Justice League and Gotham, and installing the Brother Eye satellite. However, Superman has been global for decades, LEADING the Justice League, and stopping villains who threaten the safety of the planet Earth, as opposed to a psycho who threatens the city of Gotham. Superman's problems are much bigger in scale. Take a look at their primary villains. Batman has The Joker, Freeze, Ivy, Bane, Black Mask, Two-Face, The Penguin, etc. Have any of these guys ever had any aspiration outside of Gotham City? Lex Luthor, Braniac, Zod, Doomsday, Darkseid, Bizarro, have all had plans that would have destroyed our beloved home if Superman hadn't intervened. The only example that Bat has is Ra's, and thats pushing it. Batman's fights are epic, Superman's are legendary.


#2: Superman can respond to any emergency immediately
Are you being mugged by five guys dressed as different playing cards? (The always hilarious Royal Flush Gang) Well, after crawling to the Police Station following your uninterrupted mug-stabbing, you can file a report and wait for 25 others to suffer the same thing. When the body count reaches 30 or so, then Gordon will flash the signal and explain to Batman what is happening, then your justice will be served somewhere between 7 and 10 issues later. If you are lucky enough to live in Metropolis, then you never get stabbed, because Superman needs to only change his pants before swiftly rescuing you.

#3: Superman fights for justice, Batman has a personal vendetta
There is a big difference between hero and vigilante. For instance, one would never punch a woman, and the other punches girls, all the time. Like, every issue.


#4: Superman doesn't need sidekicks
Batman has several, and Superman has none. Yes, Superboy and Supergirl are around, but they have joined teams of their own, or have grown into their own stand-alone heroes. Never, have they patrolled Metropolis together. Bruce has multiple sidekicks living with him at any given time. In his house.



#5: Superman WOULD win in a fight
Everyone's favorite, but contrary to popular belief, Superman would win this one. Sure, Batman is the world's greatest detective, and given enough time to prepare he can finish anyone, I've heard all of those arguments. But Supes has experience, a better resume, and superior abilities. There really isn't a contest here, at all. There never was. He beat Darkseid sir, fucking Darkseid. Did you read that issue? Have you heard about it? It was fucking crazy.







11 comments:

  1. You forgot the part where superman is an alien with powers that no human could possess...while batman is just like you and I and uses his natural human abilities...that alone negates every point you just made. Take away his powers an superman is nothing

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yeah, and take away Bruce Wayne's weapons and money and you got a guy who can fight but is very very mortal.

      The "Take away his powers and superman is nothing" is just dumb. They are comparing each other to the way they are.

      Delete
    2. Yeah, and take away Bruce Wayne's weapons and money and you got a guy who can fight but is very very mortal.

      The "Take away his powers and superman is nothing" is just dumb. They are comparing each other to the way they are.

      Delete
    3. Exactly, anyone can create a hypothetical situation. Thanks for reading, and more importantly, thanks for agreeing with me!

      Delete
    4. throw in some kryptonite and let's see what happens.

      Delete
  2. Yeah, if you take away all of superman's powers than he would be easy to WAIT A SECOND OH YEAH THAT ALREADY HAPPENED AND HE WON ANYWAYS https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Great_Darkness_Saga

    ReplyDelete
  3. AMEN. Best post ever about how Superman is totally better than Batman.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you! Finally, I am showered with the compliments I deserve.

      Delete
  4. One word.

    Kryptonite.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Superman would win until Batman investigates him and finds his weakness then Superman is tricked into a Kryptonite situation.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. As much as I disagree with that, it certainly is the majority opinion on what would go down.

      Delete